Custer County Sheriff Dan Osmond reports that as of Jan. 5, 2026, there are three males and no females lodged in the Custer County Jail. Current incarcerations and their charges, along with arrests made between Dec. 26, 2025, and Jan. 1, 2026, are listed below.

Lawrence Allen Millspaugh - Booked Sept. 26, 2024, serving sentence on two counts 1st degree sexual assault of a child, and two counts cruelty toward a child Sam Gary Payton - Booked Nov. 11, 2025, serving sentence for terroristic threats, Class 3 felony Jeffery Bruce Plumb - Booked Aug. 11, 2025, awaiting trial for felony possession of controlled substance Eldon James Schnase - Booked and released Jan. 1, driving under the influence of liquor Christopher Eugene Muggy - Booked Dec. 25, 2025, released Dec. 30, 2025, charged with trespassing Robert Lee Shoop - Booked Dec. 27, 2025, released Dec. 29, 2025, charged with possession of controlled substance and no operator’s license